Funny how all these craptards are just looking for posts that have some minor information wrong and then just spam "fail omgzorz lololol"
At least the OP was trying to contribute and gave pretty accurate information about what he did and what was the result ..despite the fairly obvious typo (I presume) about getting more arp/crit.
Did anyone else try this with a DK and horn of winter? It might be the only thing triggering the bug, rather than some other crit/agi buffs/pots..