[Rate] My New Sig Vs. My Current

[BrightChild]

Which sig do you think is better, also please rate.



Vs.

My Current Sig.

[EcHoEs]

Imo your current is better.
The new one's background "cuts" off in right side, looks bad imo.
Forgot to rate.. 7/10

[CarlosJ]

personally i would say sig 1, because i think it has a bit more flow to it than your current sig, your current sig also has those white patches that really ruin the flow and look odd.

i would say that sig one is a 6.5/10 and your current sig is a 5.5/10 (it the white patches were not all over the place i probably would prefer that and give it a higher rating) mainly because on both it just looks like youve smudged the render into a cloud background, and the white patches on both look strange and cancel out the light sources on the render. i think you should try adding c4d to your background to add a bit more depth and effects. also try to use the light realistically, it will help with depth, realism and making your sig look 3d. if light is coming from one way then normally the other side of the render will be darker, try using the burn tool to help with shadows