Originally Posted by
Heftydogg
You have some neat theories and metaphors, but you're looking at this from only one side. You're arguing that it'd be better business to leave the scam section as it is, but that's just for your own personal interest.
To spin-off your pizza metaphor, let's say we have a pizza corporation with 10,000 employees, 2,000 of them being thieves and steal from the register, fudge the books, cheat customers. Pizza Corp. becomes known for awesome pizza, awesome service, and scumbag employees. Suppliers and buyers become wary. CEO calls down and says to get rid of the 2,000; we don't need them, we're far more successful in other fields of the market.
Grats, we can all do math and see this is a loss. But you can't view it on the short term. Any smart business will make decisions based on long term effects. The moderation team unanimously hates the scam section and the rep it's giving the site, they carefully analyzed the effects involved with changing it, and decided it'd be better in the long run. So Pizza Corp. loses 2,000 employees, clearing their name and making room for fresh blood.
MMOwned finally cleared out the trash. Lets use your numbers and say 3,000 scammers leave because of the changes. (Probably not what they joined nor stayed for). The stats on the front page say Members: 520,122 as of posting this. Check back in a week, I bet the loss of the 3k giving MMOwned a bad rep is replaced with fresh blood. And not that a 12-15 y.o. scammer would understand this--but sometimes it's not about petty numbers. Good will and reputation will get you much farther than a quick buck.