[Rate] Rate my new Sig :D

[Volcano]

Hope it gets nice rates

:wave:

[CarlosJ]

hmm sorry i'm not too keen on it, it just doesnt look like it all matches and looks a bit simple. but as i think your new its not bad for a first try. to improve on i would say dont animate but if you really want to animate leave the text there for a while, it flashing constantly isnt that nice. also i would say that you need to blend the render with the background (try brushing it works preety well)

also your background looks quite flat despite the perspective use with the lines across the background, try to create darker and lighter patches on the sig to create depth.

[eviljoker]

hmm sorry i'm not too keen on it, it just doesnt look like it all matches and looks a bit simple. but as i think your new its not bad for a first try. to improve on i would say dont animate but if you really want to animate leave the text there for a while, it flashing constantly isnt that nice. also i would say that you need to blend the render with the background (try brushing it works preety well)

also your background looks quite flat despite the perspective use with the lines across the background, try to create darker and lighter patches on the sig to create depth.

Lols, i think it looks really cool and i like the flashing of the name 9/10

[CarlosJ]

lol thats good everyone has different opinions on something, thats why its good to post it on a forum so you get many peoples views.

i'm not saying its bad at all if their new at photoshop but when i give constructive criticism for a sig i try to give critique that will help for the future, i understand not everyone is going to be brilliant when they start graphics but telling people how to improve rather than just saying yeah it looks cooler has more benefit imo. and not saying i didnt like the flashing but i would say slow it down thats all

[Volcano]

Thank you for rate, and ok Carlosj but its a rate thing u havent rated yet

[Puff]

Lols, i think it looks really cool and i like the flashing of the name 9/10

No I'm sorry, l2rate please. Volcano If i sound harsh sorry, but you wont improve when people tell you its 9/10 blah blah.

I don't like the background it looks really tacky, try some nice brushes to blend the render with the background. So it flows more. Personally I'm not a fan of animated sig's so i wont critise that but i do think they look awful.

The text font it self dosent seam to fit.

So just keep practising, download some brushes. Don't give up

Lastly, please people learn how to rate!!

- Puff

[CarlosJ]

ok sure Volcano if you want a rating i give it a 6/10
but tbh i don't see why you want a rate, constructive criticism is more effective imo but il learn for the future then, sorry, i was just trying to explain to you what i thought was good, bad, and how you could improve.

[Shinyshoes]

Am I right to say you are not using any tutorials or guides? Although it's great to branch out on your own with photoshop it is absolutely essential to learn techniques from the pros. Trust me, every great "photoshopper" learned from someone better, and even the pros learn more and more everyday. My suggestion - Visit my thread on tutorials, I listed a few nice sites for just that. Rating - 6/10. Try to improve on blending the render in, and making it a little less simple.

[Volcano]

Thanks alot for help Puff and ty guys for the rates. i know its not one of my bests but i like it. And the text got such volcano colour. But true, maybe i should have taken a much more intresting background