[sig] rate my sig plz

[sweemoo]

yea i was trying to make a signature and this is what i came up with
i used The Gimp
so... yea rate it and all that

[Hellson]

Wicked dude!! 9/10 definatly - thats awesome

[EatUrBrains]

Yea ill give it a 9/10

[SpookyMan92]

I'm not sure of the power of Gimp (Photoshop user) So I'll give is a 8/10. Good work.

[Bloodsin]

Its nice. look at mine i used gimp. this is my first one ^^

[Vatralaus]

I'll give it a 8.5/10 it looks cool but i recommends PS..

[Puff]

Ok now i realy don't like critising on such a plus but I'm sorry, I'm going to have to. Now first off, for everyone else, when you rate a 9/10 that is pretty high, there for doing him no favors in improvement or contrsuctive critism. Please learn how to rate.

Now, the text dosen't fit what so ever, the render needs to be blended in with colour correction, layer blurs and styles. And that red background is really garish.

A very good attempt, do not give up and remember Practise makes perfect. Read tutorials, guides, use brushes; then you'll improve.

- Puff

[Minimized]

Puff's right... We ought to get ourselves a nice scale system around here, imo...

[Myth.]

I don't like to sound like I'm basing people either but here it goes, take it as constructive criticism and not as an insult. Everyone else is rating this really high, when honestly it's not worth it. It's good if your just starting and way better then my first signature I ever made. You just need to blend more to make your sigs a lot better, and a lot of the people rating 9/10 aren't looking at the amount of work put into it, aren't fully understanding the outcome, and I'm guessing they themselves aren't making signatures (or anything decent/challenging). I find people who do graphics have totally different views on work then people who don't do graphics. I'm not trying to bash on you or anyone else, just don't want the comments in this thread to get to your head. Follow tutorials and blend and your sigs will be a lot better. You aren't terrible and I've never used Gimp so I'm not sure how that is, I would give you links to good graphics forums but they are all set up tutorial-wise and such for people using photoshop not Gimp. So all in all, I say keep at it and follow tutorials and you will see a huge improvement. Tutorials part is really important, I find myself getting better and better every day from them.

[Minimized]

I'm just lurking around, agreeing with people.
Well said, Myth.
(get photoshop, btw)