1. Obtain quest - "Pa'Troll": Pa'Troll - Quest - World of Warcraft
2. Obtain quest - "Creature Comforts": Creature Comforts - Quest - World of Warcraft
3. Abandon "Pa'Troll" Quest
4. Do and Complete "Creature Comforts" Quest
5. Accept "Pa'Troll" Quest
6. Accept "Creature Comforts": Creature Comforts - Quest - World of Warcraft
The quest is somehow connected to each other, which is probably why it reset the other one when you Abandon it.
You can now pickup Creature Comforts again, don't know how many times you can repeat the quest since it's not repeatable (not blue)... I think this also might have occurred on the other 3 quests which you need to do for Pa Troll but haven't tested.
Here is a screenshot for proof of my completing the "Creature Comforts": Creature Comforts - Quest - World of Warcraft and then obtaining it again after accepting "Pa'Troll": Pa'Troll - Quest - World of Warcraft , they output the same questId of 12599.
Also is a reputable quest for Argent Crusade reputation faction
![]()