For some reason, I wasn't able to loot old crafty the first couple times it came up for me. The croc dropped the same time as old crafty both times and I was able to loot him but not the fish. Came back here and read the thing about the raid and that worked perfectly. If you're unable to loot the fish, invite anyone to your group and convert to raid and the quest item doesn't drop and you're able to loot. I got my third one that I was able to actually loot after about 5 casts. Good luck guys![]()