Guys, get MySQL-Front 4.2, it really works like a charm! The reason why it didn't work for me before was because I used an outdated version that wasn't really compatible with the newer MySQL files.
Important note:
When you import the sql file, make sure the coding matches your database or you get loads of errors and it may even crash!
My advice: Create a database that uses the utf8 coding and import the sql file with the same coding (pick it from the drop down list when you choose the sql file). In my case it imported the whole database in 11:44min with no errors at all