WoW or GuildWars?

[vamnon]

Actually when I wanted to start playing one of these I checked reviews where WoW won hands down. Not satisfied I went to Guild Wars forums and saw a lot of things like, "I wish I had stuck with WoW" and like "If Guild Wars wasn't free I'd be playing WoW" in the end I decided to pay more for a better game.

[leadedmoose]

heres my opinoin of the stats in both games (ive played both (but got addicted to WoW lol))

graphics:
GW- 8.5
WoW- 7.0

gameplay
GW- 6.5
WoW- 9.5

freeroam
GW- 3.3
WoW- 9.7

size
GW- 6.7
WoW- 9.3

fun
GW- 7.4
WoW- 9.8

addiction
GW- 7.5
WoW- 10.0

amount of possible things to do
GW- 3.4
WoW- 9.9

community
GW- 5.4
WoW- 8.9

battle gameplay (PvP)
GW- 6.8
WoW- 9.2

fighting style
GW- 8.5
WoW- 8.4

creativity
GW- 5.6
WoW- 9.6

quests
GW- 6.7
WoW- 9.8

NPC's/monsters
GW-6.7
WoW- 9.9

[zeds69dead]

Guildwars blows... Wow is godly


hell id rather play SWG > Guildwars

[Jidery]

lol def wow if you got the monney

[Enfeebleness]

You're asking a WoW based forum.

Jees, i wonder how people are going to respond.

[Squirllz]

WoW > gw, and yes I've played both games.

WoW has a better community, easier game play, and much more fun imo.

[Xestrikers]

You're asking a WoW based forum.

Jees, i wonder how people are going to respond.

But then again, we all chose WoW. My review -

Amount of players
GW: 8.0
WoW: 10.0

Creativity
GW: -5 (Sorry, but it looks just like an old version of China)
WoW: 9.9

PvP
GW: 6.3
WoW: 9.5

Movement
GW: 3.1
WoW: 9.2

Equipment
GW: 5.0
WoW: 7.8

Free will
GW: <Restricted rating>
WoW: 8.7

Cost:
GW: 9.0 (Expansions, expansions, GW2, GW2 COMING EXPANSIONS!!)
WoW: 3.0 (Buy it once, small monthly fee)

There you have it, WoW wins.

I played GWs, hated it. The only thing enjoyable is the graphics but i would rather play Vanguard if that were the case.

[Enfeebleness]

I liked GWs originality in the pvp arena things, i like that lava idea.


But the economy is terrible.

"WTS
WTS
WTS
WTS
WTS
WTS
WTS
WTS
WTS"
"Oh you're interested?"
-"Sorry, wrong person"
"WTS
WTS
WTS"
....

[finger19]

Graphics
Guild Wars- 9/10
WoW- 9.2/10

In my opinion Guild Wars has a loooot better graphics then WoW. But I can't imagine WoW with really good graphics. I am just used to that.

[The-Invisible-One]

:wave: Hello Everyone :wave:

Funny you ask this at a WoW Forum :P
But I played GW for a long time, Even when I liked WoW Better,
The Reason: Not enough money,
You keep paying for WoW, GW is one time buy so thats better, but then again, if you want to stay with the game you have to buy a new part every 6 months I thought.

But now I play WoW Private (Hope the Real WoW Players dont mind)
So thats better

Conclusion:

WoW:

+
Good graphics.
Lotta People Play.
You can do what u want.
Nice Armor etc.

-
Monthly Fee.
Overplayed realms/places.
Storyline sometimes fades.
Some armors are the same but just a different color



GW:

+
Nice Storyline
One Time Purchase
New Part Every 6 Months
Nice Armor
Good Graphics

-
Storyline MUST Be Followed.
New Part Has To Be Bought Every 6 Months
New Part Has To Be Bought Every 6 Months
Armor TOO Expensive, Cannot Be Found
Party's Are Too Small
Low Population On Most Parts Of The Story

:hsdance: I Prefer WoW :hsdance:

Greetz,
The-Invisible-One

[kastelo]

for me WoW i love t :P

[ryanster]

wow all the way

[miklm]

You really can't compare the two. They are totally different games, yeah sure they're both RP games but WoW has its aspects and so does Guild Wars. I play both and I would say I play more WoW, but because of the fees;will probably be playing GW in the end.

Graphics
Guild Wars- 9/10
WoW- 9.2/10

Gameplay
Guild Wars 8/10
WoW 9/10

Story
Guild Wars 10/10
WoW 4/10

Originality
Guild Wars 10/10
WoW 9/10

/agree
Wow's story sucks... GW's is pretty good tho

[Wesk.]

/agree
Wow's story sucks... GW's is pretty good tho

hmm i dont agree with ya =/. I think world of warcraft story is like 1203102391 million pages long if you add all warcraft games together =/.
And its real fun to read all it at wowwiki.

[Dimmy353]

wow is the seguent of the warcraft strategy game and wow have the bigest fantasy ever taurens , undeads , elves , night elfs , gnomes that is good and the map of wow is too big and it have good quest to done and good items chest and armours.
GW is a new game ok it have god grafics but is tooooo real please we need to be in a fantasy to exit from the s*** we make every day for some hours only.
Blizzard for ever!