Rate my sig

[323122tm]

Rate it plox 1/10

[Zoidberg]

Did a major cleanup.
Come on guys... Don't bug him because of a typo or spelling.

Serious comments/ratings from now on.

[d3rrial]

Serious rating: 2/10 I posted that before.
Awful Text, Awful Text Placement, Way to Big, Uninteresting Render, Completely unblended render, nice colors.

[Remus]

still not proper cnc, that's ripping on his signature, offer ways to fix it.. suggestions to improve beyond pointing out the obvious.

[Dobbs]

try to make you sig around 450*150 or smaller, also blend the render in, using smudge etc. Finally go to Dafont.com and dowmload a font that fits in with the render. 1.5/5 ok for a start.

[alj03]

I am going to agree with Dobbs here. Obviously, we all know that it is way too big. Usually sigs are around 350-450*100-150. Change that and you will be one step closer to making better sigs. Personally I like the text, although it is not in a very good position. Also try blending in the render more. If your looking for tutorials for signature making check out this site: Photoshop Signature Tutorials - SigTutorials.com

Hope this helped a little.

[DarkVanir]

Agreed with _SkHiEnEgP_. 2/10

[Sneakylemons]

still not proper cnc, that's ripping on his signature, offer ways to fix it.. suggestions to improve beyond pointing out the obvious.

That kinda is proper CC, you aren't supposed to tell the OP EXACTLY how to fix it, you tell them what is wrong and let them figure out how to fix it on their own, or else it wouldn't be critiquing it would just be telling them what to do, making it harder for them to actually learn =\

[Remus]

That kinda is proper CC, you aren't supposed to tell the OP EXACTLY how to fix it, you tell them what is wrong and let them figure out how to fix it on their own, or else it wouldn't be critiquing it would just be telling them what to do, making it harder for them to actually learn =\

except they haven't a clue how to do it(otherwise it wouldn't have been done), CnC also means passing on tips and wisdom learned, which the quoted thereby is not proper CnC but a total downer.

I can pick out flaws in my artwork as well... doesn't mean I know how to fix them.

[Reflection]

I have to agree with Remus here, it's not constructive criticism, in my opinion, when someone says that "this and that is bad". In comparison, "this and that is bad, and you should try this or maybe that to improve it by moving it somewhere else or changing the color", IS constructive criticism. Anyone can bash on what that looks ugly but at least I won't take one's word for something if they have no suggestions on how to improve it. It's just a rather hollow statement with nothing to back it up.

[Sneakylemons]

My bad, I see what you're saying.