First signature (want feedback)

[grandmst20]

1. Right, I was just saying that's what it looked like.

2. I never mentioned your name, let alone suggested anything about you.

3. The only one with smudge is the Samus one, and this thread isn't about me or you, chief. I didn't ask you for critique, I provided examples to enforce my point.

4. Did you read the text after it? Apparently not.

Good thing this thread isn't about you because you take criticism poorly.

-------------------------

Now, hopefully someone can get back on subject about helping cedsson, I added my feedback.

[Dobbs]

bad[/I] style, but let the guy work out what he likes. My style changes per render and what looks best.

If you cared to look at any of the new thread made by me. You would know how much I have improved since me posting on this thread.
Take this sig for instance:

This was made by me and I haven't used a single brush in it. Also everyone has their own style.

Take you for instance all these sigs look the same 'style'.

[grandmst20]

You guys fail to see the point. I don't really care if you've improved. I made a simple statement that those 3 sigs you posted were the same style and looked the same. I don't really care about your style. And if those 3 sigs I posted look the same style, that's fine, I wasn't really going for anything, I simply uploaded 3 sigs I made a few years ago to give an idea of color flow, and how sigs don't have to be 1 color.

You guys are really getting butthurt over a thread about criticism. You posted images and thoughts in relation to helping cedsson, as did I.

[Reflection]

Enough with the flaming. Get back on the topic or simply stay out, it's getting ridiculous. Give him some criticism or move on.

Thank you.

[Aes]

No offense but that render looks kinda bad. No matter what you did here is what I took from it: Color added to generated clouds, Deathwing render sharpened about 6 times or more (too many), shadow added around the edge. Smudging != always perfection. Sometimes smudging is not the best option for the render. However, it is worth noting that with the right person, smudging can be applied to the above render. Could I pull it off? I'm not sure...it's a trial and error kinda thing. From the looks of it I would possibly try another method.

I did NOT add generated clouds, they are c4ds, brushes etc. I started with the render oversized and smudged it.
What i did to that signature was from Reflections tutorial. Every step i took was from his tutorial. It is NOT my render someone requested that as a signature.

But just keep playing around with the signatures, youll get the hand of them pretty easy once you know what you need to do.