[Show-Off] My new sig

[-xepher-]

Rate it plx.

[sheepking]

Because I hate C4D's (Cuz I can't use them xD) you'll only earn 7/10 Points, because the rest is nice

[Krip]

4.5/10
Honestly, There is lots of work to do. First of all, the signature itself does not have a good flow to it. There is no text, and it seems like you just dropped some c4ds, then brushes, and finally you just added clouds and other effects.
You should try to follow some tutorials, because C4D's can look nice if you know how to blend them in.
Keep trying, keep practicing.
This post was made not to let you down, but to make you better.

[Volcano]

it looks like it have been matted out in one picture.. bad.. 4/10

[-xepher-]

4.5/10
Honestly, There is lots of work to do. First of all, the signature itself does not have a good flow to it. There is no text, and it seems like you just dropped some c4ds, then brushes, and finally you just added clouds and other effects.
You should try to follow some tutorials, because C4D's can look nice if you know how to blend them in.
Keep trying, keep practicing.
This post was made not to let you down, but to make you better.

Heh, i only used c4ds and no brushes, its a pattern. I followed a tutorial and the guy that made the tutorial gave it a 8/10 so i dont get why the ratings are so low, everyone i know gave it a high rating 7/10+

[Krip]

When I began making signatures, and for over two years I thought the signatures I made were AWESOME but I also received some low ratings and some high ones. Now, since I have been designing for over three years I understand this. You shall understand when you get better also. Just take my word, keep practicing. This signature is definitely not a 7+. Don't get down because what I said, just keep practicing.

[Piersd]

c4d doesn't fit in imo. I don't really like all the splatter in the background or the colour. also theres no border lol

[^Xayo]

8.5/10
Nice although there are points to improve

[Romis]

Well, I would only give you a 5. I do not like the whole image as itself, and you should add text somewhere. Otherwise people can rip it, and that's always annoying :P

And what's that thing above his head?

[CarlosJ]

Heh, i only used c4ds and no brushes, its a pattern. I followed a tutorial and the guy that made the tutorial gave it a 8/10 so i dont get why the ratings are so low, everyone i know gave it a high rating 7/10+

i would say that comment backs up peoples arguments perfectly. if you followed someones tutorial of a sig they obviously think are good and they only gave you 8/10 for it (so that means its 2 off being as good as theres and tbh i cant imagine the original version of this being anymore than a 7 or

sometimes you dont need to follow a tutorial exactly how its written, its good to add your own edge.
also you said you used no brushes and c4d only, this was also a problem, you need to use brushes to blend the c4d with the sig a bit more, they stand out too much.

personally id give it a 6/10, you may see this or other comments posted as negative but i believe constructive criticism to be more helpful than just saying "9/10 looks wicked" it may seem harsh to say but you are always going to like your work more than others do, but that doesnt mean its bad, it means we all see work differently and it provides an incentive for you to keep trying, improving and show others better work you can produce and how you can improve.