[Rate/Critique?] Some new sigs... which one should i use?

[Piersd]

Tried a new style that my bro showed me (he's pretty good...). All i use is a c4d/s and just duplicate and do all this other stuff. I haven't used any brushes in these, just the default ones. Also i can't decide which one to use as my sig, so i would like you to suggest which one and maybe if you feel like it, why?

1. 2.

P.S I wasn't sure what the tags should be...

[CarlosJ]

i really like this kind of sigs personally, i like the abstract kind of style. i think number 1 is the better sig because of the range of colour tones, the lighting looks clearer and it has more depth than the green one. dont get me wrong though green one is still nice just i think it is a bit to "covered" in green and needs a bit more negative space to contrast it.

al though personally i would use the green one as i really like green :P i think that the blue one is graphically better
also text looks nice on both of them, tag wise; sorry no ideas that are vaguely good

[Piersd]

thanks for the comments I probably need some better c4ds to make these, the blue one was pretty good, but the green one was i dunno, too busy maybe... if that makes sense

[CarlosJ]

but the green one was i dunno, too busy maybe... if that makes sense

yeahh i understand, busy was the word i was looking for lol but i said covered instead:confused: just wasn't as clean as the blue one i think thats all

[Piersd]

i should start making my own renders, but its time consuming and i gotta get all this stuff and do all this shiz etc... guess im just lazy lol

[Krip]

Use the first, it's much nicer.
The font also blends in very nice.

[Piersd]

i had trouble getting a good font to fit with the second one. I spent a while going through and couldn't be bothered anymore and just randomly chose one lol