[Sig Battle] Massi vs. Bob_Magic

[Bob_Magic]

haha thanks I like yours more though, my vote is you

[Massimiliano]

haha thanks I like yours more though, my vote is you

Thanks a bunch!

[Frogzilla]

Bob IMHO! filler

[jzf]

I'm going for Massi. Because I know how hard it is to use a human render and for it to come out that good.

[CarlosJ]

bob - purely because i think he has blended it better, dont get me wrong yours is nice but youve just put a render on a nice bacground, if you had added something to blend the two layers together (brushes, c4d etc i think it would be better) hope that helps.

[Massimiliano]

bob - purely because i think he has blended it better, dont get me wrong yours is nice but youve just put a render on a nice bacground (Massi: ROFLROFLROFLROFL), if you had added something to blend the two layers together (brushes, c4d etc i think it would be better) hope that helps.

Stupidity and drinking owns me

[CarlosJ]

sorry since when has that ever been a rule not to blend human renders, sure it may be hard but theres no rule against it




three sigs with human renders, they are blended i dont seee your point? human redners can be blended, you may not like blending them or find it hard but doesnt mean you shouldnt. as you know so much about grafics you should know that as its about expressing your ideas and designs there are no rules or limitations that arent physical. perhaps judging by the genral consensus that people prefer bobs maybe you should try blending human renders in future even though it may be against the 'rules'.
also i really dont see why you 'lol' at me saying youve put a render on a background because that is what you have done, remove the background it is just a render, remove the render its a background, jeez why post your work for feedback if you cant take criticisim

[Massimiliano]

sorry since when has that ever been a rule not to blend human renders, sure it may be hard but theres no rule against it.

Three sigs with human renders, they are blended i dont seee your point? human redners can be blended, you may not like blending them or find it hard but doesnt mean you shouldnt. as you know so much about grafics you should know that as its about expressing your ideas and designs there are no rules or limitations that arent physical. perhaps judging by the genral consensus that people prefer bobs maybe you should try blending human renders in future even though it may be against the 'rules'.
also i really dont see why you 'lol' at me saying youve put a render on a background because that is what you have done, remove the background it is just a render, remove the render its a background, jeez why post your work for feedback if you cant take criticisim

Stupidity and drinking owns me

[Bob_Magic]

I can see where carlosj is coming from, but my current signature is not much different from the style of massi's

[Pullefjun]

I like massis alot, but the shadow and the pink and the render makes me dizzy :/
Vote Bob :/

[CarlosJ]

oki Masi i'm not going to have an argument over it, obviously we both have different views, good luck to you. i never said that your sig was bad i just gave you improvements just like you asked, if you cant take it then thats not my fault. keep following the 'rules' but i dont think you always have to.even though i still dont get your point about that not being a render and a background put together il live with it theres more important things in life, and no its not "wrong and stupid" to say that because thats my observation and as i previously pointed out removing the render would just leave a background, which is what it is.

@bob yeah i see what you mean but what i would say about your sig is that you have added brushes behind the render and the blue laser line. if they wernt there then i would say it follows same styles as masis but because youve added these they give an effect to the render so it is not just a render. removing the render from yours it would look abit strange as it would feel as though someting is missing as opposed to masims i feel you could use as a sig without the render.

[Massimiliano]

oki Masi i'm not going to have an argument over it, obviously we both have different views, good luck to you. i never said that your sig was bad i just gave you improvements just like you asked, if you cant take it then thats not my fault. keep following the 'rules' but i dont think you always have to.even though i still dont get your point about that not being a render and a background put together il live with it theres more important things in life, and no its not "wrong and stupid" to say that because thats my observation and as i previously pointed out removing the render would just leave a background, which is what it is.

@bob yeah i see what you mean but what i would say about your sig is that you have added brushes behind the render and the blue laser line. if they wernt there then i would say it follows same styles as masis but because youve added these they give an effect to the render so it is not just a render. removing the render from yours it would look abit strange as it would feel as though someting is missing as opposed to masims i feel you could use as a sig without the render.

Morning- I must say im quite sorry bout the messeages i left ya last night... Was quite off and away, so my apologies. Thanks for the feedback and i can now see what you mean. =)

[CarlosJ]

lol aw wel thanks, apologies accepted then keep up the gfx

[Tinky]

Vote for Bob, gaming signatures in a game forum :-)

[Bob_Magic]

8:3 I think That finalizes it, Because it's been 5 days now...
Does that mean i win?