Heroic Bryntroll or Shadow's Edge?

[bloodshed794]

Which is better? Heroic Bryntroll or Shadow's Edge? DO NOT SAY HEROIC BYRNTROLL BECUASE OF ITS GS. Thanks for all of your help and sorry for the quick post

[Illidan_000]

Well i'd go for the Byntroll, it has an imba proc on heroic and also a higher DPS + 1 more socket and increased stats. if you have it do not replace it for shadow's edge, why? you waste 25 primordials for nothing when Cataclysm is going to come out this year so waste of gold, you should better sell them or if u didnt bought them just save your gold.

EDIT: Overall Byntrol HC.

[Lemour]

I would also go for the Byntroll... Beacuse of the proc and the fact that its the best wep before you can grab your hands around Shadowmourne! Btw what class is going to wield it ?

[swankboss]

I would also agree, if your capable of getting the heroic Byntroll, get it.

[kingsquid]

I believe Bryntoll is better

[Lorandos]

Just test it : Rawr - Elitist Jerks

[vuvuzela]

277>264

[Livewire]

Bryntroll idd but if you're guild is capable of killing LK25HC then go for weaps from there if you're not close to getting Smourne.

[Chronic1337]

Heroic Bryntroll.

I use Heroic Cryptmaker mainhand and shadow's edge offhand since im stacking armor pen, but heroic bryntroll would be better

[wicked_joe]

Wotlk=Where killing heroics isn't enough to know the obvious answer to which gear is better

[AustinM]

Idiots, Bryntoll is a pretty shitty weapon unless you use it for Unholy. If your spec is gemming arp, keep Shadow's Edge.

[Sfryk]

If u mean pvp Brynntroll, you shud srsly say which class you are cuz of the ARP, Let's say your a dk then i wud use Brynntroll in pve and pvp, if youre a pala bryntroll easy if your a warrior it depends on your current arp but i think id go with bryntroll there 2 :>