I'm torn!

[hav0kZA]

Really I am. I'm torn between 2 servers with a difficult choice.

Here's my story -

For those of you who don't know Neverendless has SLOWLY been dying a very laggy and crashy death, I wasn't going to stick around to see it happen because I was getting frustrated with all of the lag,crashes and well to put it straight and simple the instances were not exactly 'FUN'.

So now I've got 2 places to run to; MagicWoW or Molten-WoW

So I made a Pros/Con list of both

MagicWoW

Pros :
-Almost completely lagless (No lag spikes at all)
-Awesome uptime
-Scripted instances are awesomely scripted! with phases! (None of that randomly casting spells bullshit)
-Constant updates (Marcelo and the bunch are really working their butts off)
-Huge Player base (Around 4k+)
-Most of the talents working

Cons :
-Uptime has been slipping
-Only has up to Naxx (Ulduar and ToC hasn't been released yet, altough Ulduar is nearing release)
-Things like ArP and such don't work
-Still some talents not working

Molten-WoW, Now this server I don't really know much about (I only played until like level 20) but atm it looks quite attractive because it's been up without a crash for like 4 days now without any serious lag (Not as good as Magic-WoW though).

Whats bothering me though is that it's owned by Kaer and BeepBeep who were both working at NE (Kaer being one of the main devs for their 'Orange Core'). For that reason I guessed that they are using a branched or whatever version of 'Orange Core' (Which is SUPER LAGGY and crashy) which will pretty soon, after they hit that magical 1500 population number, inherit the same problems that NE have atm. (And I doubt that their instances are as thoroughly scripted in comparison with MagicWoW)

Another reason why I'm asking is because I'm planning on 'donating' to which ever one I plan on staying with.

tl;dr WoWMagic vs Molten-WoW, who's better.

a sub note, yes, I AM asking for your personal opinion.

[warsheep]

Based from your pros and cons, magicWoW without doubt.

Even though the uptime is slipping, that really isn't bad if it's kept to less then once per day.
Since Molten-WoW are doing the same mistake again, it's no doubt that the developers doesn't learn. And that is some of the worst flaws through emulation >_<

MagicWoW seems all in all more professional, and better. I'd go with them if I were in your situation.

[hav0kZA]

Thank you for the reply

I have decided to go with MagicWoW because even though MoltenWoW is better at the moment (More working spells, super uptime) it's all still a uncertainty what will happen when they hit a high popuplation where I know what Magic can handle.

Keep well

[DeadlyMaker]

I have tested Molten WoW, in my opinion it's not that good, the instances are really poorly scripted. You are able to donate for items from Togc, even if they haven't opened it on the realm itself yet. In the future there will be custom ones, like NE had as well.

Sure, they might have a good uptime, but I prefer a challenge and hardwork besides uptime tbh.

[zantetzou]

Molten WoW is a fake. Their pop/uptime counter is off and the management is immature.

Go anywhere except molten