DPS Charts for Profiles

[healzzz]

Hi there,
I'm wondering why there isn't a DPS chart comparison between available profiles? Wouldn't that be interesting and perhaps also push the quality forward?

If you do test, please conduct the test the following way in order to have a somewhat level playing field:

!!!PLEASE INCLUDE SCREENSHOTS IN YOUR POSTS OF DPS REPORTS!!!

- Test Profiles on Raid Dummy's
- 3 Test-Runs, 50m damage done each run
- Always wear the same base equipment
- Report Skada Total DMG and DPS numbers

For you gear, please include the following stats and info:
- DPS
- Item Level
- Tier bonus (2pc/4pc)
- Mastery
- Haste
- Spellpower
- Hit
- Crit
- Expertise
- Attack Power

Please also post your Talent Tree & Glyphs using the wowhead talent calculator

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tests & Results ::: RESET FOR 5.4


MONK


WARLOCK


PALDIN


DEATH KNIGHT


WARRIOR

Type: Single Target, 50M Damage, Orgrimmar

Info: SMF, IL 545, 4 Set T15

Stats: DPS: 14,172 / 11,534
Attack Power: 40,536
Haste: 4,141
Hit: 5,776
Crit: 15,304
Exp: 2,246
Mastery: 6780

Profiles: Replikator's Ultimate [Paid] VS. Soapbox Elite [Paid]

Attachment 15765

Conclusion: I enjoy both of these profiles. i have been using Soapbox's a lot longer then Replikators but i have come to prefer Rep's. There is not a huge difference in DPS have but Rep's profile seems to run a little more smooth. He has also taken the time to add some coding for the Evil Eye trinket and they easy access to a keybind for Bladestorm is wonderful.

Profiles: Mavmins Fury Profile

Attachment 15767

Conclusion: Compare to my other profile runs! Good profile considering it is free, feels a little choppy, a little like Soap's profile does. Has a lot of options but not enough buttons to put the options on. Needs to set up some macro commands!

If anyone has other profiles they would like me to run to compare to these just send me a message!

SHAMAN

Test by healzzz

Info: ilvl 560, 2pc T16, 2pc T15
SimCraft 5.40-4 Patchwerk-5m-noBuffs: 205k DPS

Elemental Shaman Face-Off: Soapbox Elite vs. Mavmins Profile

Soapbox Elemental Shaman Elite Profile


Mavmins Elemental Profile


Conclusion: Both profiles are in a dead heat. Given that Soapbox's Elite profiles do count as some of the best out there, Mavmins work is even more impressive. I personally like the "Macro" approach that Soapbox is pursuing more than the 50 options that Mavmin is giving you, but again that is very subjective and down to personal taste. In terms of performance, there profiles deliver. However, both profiles are around 10k dps away from the "SimCrafted" numbers so there might be ways to further improve them. Clearly, the opening I feel could be optimized with a specific opener script, something that I had especially hoped for from a paid profile such as Soap's.

MAGE


DRUID


ROGUE

Hello!!, i have a 527 ilvl geared rogue, is subtlety.

Info:

AP: 53057
Agi: 26348
Exp: 7.50%/7.50%
Haste: 38.74%
Hit: 7.51%
Crit: 27.37%
Mast: 42.84%

No tier bonus.

Trinkets: Assurance of Consequence (SoO Flex upgraded, 548 ilvl) and Renataki's Soul Charm (ToT Normal upgraded, 530 ilvl)

Talents are:

Subterfuge, Combat Readiness, Leeching Poison, Cloack and Dagger, Prey on the Weak and Anticipation

Gliphs are:

Redirect, Hemorrhaging Veins and Sprint

Here are my reviews of two profiles. One is Blinded (Starl1te version, update to 5.4) and onther is Soapbox Elite (Paid version).


Raid Dummy Boss Blinded, 450s in combat. All cooldowns, with vanish. Deadly Poison.
Attachment 16143
Attachment 16142
Raid Dummy Boss Soapbox Elite, 450s in combat. All cooldowns, with vanish. Wound Poison.
Attachment 16153
Attachment 16152
Raid Dummy Boss Soapbox Elite, 450s in combat. All cooldowns, with vanish. Deadly Poison.
Attachment 16154
Attachment 16155
Immerseus LFR, Soapbox Elite
Attachment 16145Attachment 16144
The Fallen Protectors LFR, Soapbox Elite
Attachment 16149Attachment 16148
Norushen LFR, Soapbox Elite, All combat with 75p of corruption , I didn't go to the event.
Attachment 16147Attachment 16146
Sha of Pride LFR, Soapbox Elite.
Attachment 16151Attachment 16150

Blinded and Raid10 coming soon.

Combat Rogue!

MaskedArmory: Click

Talents: Click

Type: Single Target, 50M Damage, Orgrimmar, Raider's Training Dummy

Info: 534 ILvL, 2pc T16, /wo Vanish

Stats:
DPS: 14,040/12,222
Attack Power: 58,264
Haste: 12,287
Hit: 2,608
Crit: 4,488
Exp: 1,871
Mastery: 6092

Profiles: Neyia Rogue Profiles VS. starl1te Rogue Profiles [Free]

PRIEST


HUNTER

[qichang]

i theory good idea, but not everyone has the same gear

[healzzz]

WHAT?!? Thats an insane statement!

No i realize that but a good rotation shouldn't be half as good with 15 ilvls more or less, no?

[Zoinx]

WHAT?!? Thats an insane statement!

No i realize that but a good rotation shouldn't be half as good with 15 ilvls more or less, no?

Wrong. Depends on the class, trinkets and mostly weapons someone has.

[Lexi777]

Still a good idea, DPS charts comparing each CR and healing charts. Just state your iLvl and class

[shuklu]

I've been thinking about this a long time, as I have all 8 chars running lfr each week. Good idea, imo.

[healzzz]

I will start doing this. Target is a raid dummy, will use single-target rotation. Will start with Demonology WL

[BadFuryWarrior]

Lots of variables though. One being bias and manipulating the screenshot.

ilvl isn't the be-all-end-all of determining how much DPS will be produced. You've got enchants, gems and reforges too, as well as just how the character's stats are built.

It would only really be good for comparing several profiles run on one character which hasn't been altered between using each profile.

[healzzz]

Test 1 - Warlock Demonology
Talent&Glyph Spec: Mists of Pandaria - Talent Calculator - World of Warcraft
Item Level: 518
Buffs: Dark Intent

Key Stats
Tier Bonus: None
Mastery: 23.99%
Haste: 11.40%
Spellpower: 29,460
Hit: 15,89%
Crit: 14.55%

Profiles Tested
Target: Raid Dummy
Time: 5x 20 Million dmg
DPS Meter: Skada (up-to-date)

Mentally's Hysteria - single target w. automatic cooldowns
Average DPS: 75.3k

Soapbox Elite Raiding Profile (Paid) - Boss w. automatic cooldowns
Average DPS: 81.3k

Soapbox Ultimate Raiding Profiles (Free) - Boss
Average DPS: 73.7k

[healzzz]

oh please let me know if I have missed a Demo profile that you'd like me to test

[Gabbz]

lol...

Hello SoapBox !!!!

[Gabbz]

Here comes mine testing similiar states and shir


Test 1 - Warlock Demonology
Talent&Glyph Spec: Mists of Pandaria - Talent Calculator - World of Warcraft
Item Level: 518
Buffs: Dark Intent

Key Stats
Mastery: 23.99%
Haste: 11.40%
Spellpower: 29,460
Hit: 15,89%
Crit: 14.55%

Profiles Tested
Target: Raid Dummy
Time: 5x 20 Million dmg
DPS Meter: Skada (up-to-date)

Mentally's Hysteria - single target w. automatic cooldowns
Average DPS: 85.3k

Soapbox Elite Raiding Profile (Paid) - Boss w. automatic cooldowns
Average DPS: 81.3k

Soapbox Ultimate Raiding Profiles (Free) - Boss
Average DPS: 73.7k

[Gabbz]

BTW did you see the problem....

[Apocalypse59]

BTW did you see the problem....

Nice one Gabbz. +rep

[maceyp]

Great idea, however instead of just saying your current Ilvl why dont you include how much set bonus you have like T15 (2) or T15(4) etc as this will make difference