[RATE] My signatures.

[[M]illo]

Hey guys.
I'm kinda new with this photoshop program, but i did my best to make some signatures.
I would like that you rated them on a scale on 10.
And please give a comment.

My 1st:


My 2nd:


My 3rd:


My 4th (current sig) :


My 5th which was inspired by Nemorosa :

GOGO flame:P

[CarlosJ]

its a bit hard 2 rate them overall out of 10 as i feel some sigs are better than others
and as i dont like to be negative where i cant find constructive things to say i leave it (e.g. no2 im not to keen on but cannot see where to improve)

overall for the sigs i give 7/10
4th one i really like, abstract feel is very simple but effective and i liek that kind of style, no 5 i think would look nicer if u added a mask to the shadow and added a gradient fill.
3rd one i feel is a bit to simple and basic, the text needs to blend more with the background and the render looks as though youve just placed it there, i think you should add brushing, (use burn tool ) around it to create dark light patches to add depth.
first sig just seems a bit plain and the render doesnt really fit with the rest of the sig, try adding c4d or something to the background to add depth and variation and introduce some more colours into the sig