[Rate please] Catalyst's Signatures

[XC4T4LY5TX]

Sup All you people of mmowned viewing this.

Rate the sig's i made with PS CS3.

1

2

3
4


Rate each one thx

Just so people arent like " Wtf who is skooter " thats me, an napua is a g/f

[CarlosJ]

ok il rate out of 10 if you want each rated:
6/10
810
5.5/10
4/10

sorry if they seem bit low but thats my ratings for them, il explain why aswel incase you want improvements
1.seem kinda messy on the right hand side,the swirls look like they have half been covered/highlighted over using other things so it leaves a weird square around it. text is a bit to ovbious, try not to use the glow effect at such a high setting and blur it more into the sig. also the lighting is messed up as its on the bottom of the render but top of the background.
2. i like this sig alot, the effects are good on it, the lighting on the render is good. its the right side of the sig i think lets it down. try to add a bit more colour to the sig as it just looks like youve used a filter on it which has removed on colouring. also blend the c4d a bit more into the background as they stand out to much and justlook like theyve been placed ontop. so yeah would give higher rating but right side lets it down imo
3. preety simple really, the background is simple with a render ontop of it, the colours seem faded though, and the text takes up to much room on the sig. try to add more effects to the background to make it a bit more intersting and blend the render with the background
4.text is way to big should be alot smaller as it take up nearly all the sig. the render should be in the centre of the circle so you can see it more, im comfused really what the sig is meant to show/represent anything like that as the render has too low an opacity, and the 'background' looks very strange

hope some the comments helped

[The Metal]

My ratings:

1. 7/10
2. 10/10 VERY NICE!
3. 5.5/10
4. 5.5/10

[Sonic Waffle]

7/10
8/10
6/10
5/10
Nice!

[XC4T4LY5TX]

in number 4 i have an the hand of the guy from assassins creed behidn the blue orb
. thx for the ratings, i just finished my newest aniamted sigs

5

6

[CarlosJ]

lol o right thanks for pointing out makes kinda more sense now.
on the new sigs.i like number one it is preety kool. however the animation is a bit mucked up when the filter disappears so the image changes colour. try to slow the animation down aswell its hard to read the text
for the last animated one i think the idea behind it is preety cool but if you blended the animation it would look smoother and better. theres like three ooo at the bottom of the animation timeline which change the effects between frames so you can use this to add more frames where the colour blends between the two backgrounds instead of having such a huge jump

[Skozzan]

I love the signatures!! Great job and +Rep if I could.. And yeah.. How do you like my new signature??

|
v

[XC4T4LY5TX]

good 1 skozz