Rate my Sigs please

[jcako]

hey guys if you can, can you plz have a look over my sigs and tell me what you guys think? constructive critisizem is always welcome (oh and be nice ive only had photoshop for like 2 days) PS sorry i have to use photobucket it wont let me upload to mmonwed.

first one:

http://i241.photobucket.com/albums/f...-LICH-KING.gif

second one:

http://i241.photobucket.com/albums/f.../Lightwave.gif

Third one:

http://i241.photobucket.com/albums/f...t7/jcako-1.gif

fourth one :

http://i241.photobucket.com/albums/f...zenCrusade.gif

Fith one:

http://i241.photobucket.com/albums/f...me_Layer-2.gif

thx for looking and remeber constuctive critisim is a must

PPS i no i no there all text lol
just made the warrior one first one that is graphic.
http://i241.photobucket.com/albums/f...arrior-Sig.gif

[cgrock]

what do you use for your animation's?

[jcako]

image ready

[Assisted]

I would rate them 5/10 they're just plain with animations =\

[Puff]

I know you stated that there only text.. but it is... you can't expect a high rating on just text and my opinion most people must know now is that i hate animated sigs :P they look tacky and awful ^^

But its just my opinion alot of the people love them

Keep it up just ad in a render, background, a suited colour theme, border and your well away...

[Tinky]

It's good, a text animation.

But simple .)

[Roller]

not even worth a 2/10... 2005 > Animation

[Zoidberg]

There is a typo in the first sig. Its "Wrath of the lich king" not "WraIth of the lich king"

[Volcano]

Rate of all 6/10 Maybe 7/10 Nice done, specially the warrior one but its quite annoying with the light on the sword keeps go on.

[Remahlól]

The fifth is good, nice scan bar, but making it a bit smothing wouldn't be bad.

[demonred22]

is my siggy pic... needs to be resized KB wise but Remah is doing that for me right now... want to rate mine?... *looks up* REMAH! lol....im bored

[jcako]

is my siggy pic... needs to be resized KB wise but Remah is doing that for me right now... want to rate mine?... *looks up* REMAH! lol....im bored

8/10 id give it but the text is a bit hard to read

[Minimized]

There's a show-off thread. Post stuff like this there instead.