[Showoff/Rate/Suggestions]

[cgrock]

Here is my first attempt at sigs in awhile.
Please rate these 0-10 Thanks
Give me suggestions on what i should change in my work





I realize this one is awful because of where i messed up (don't criticize on that please) thanks

[Clain]

heres some CC.

1. Don't use the same font everytime (In some sigs try making it small)
2. It needs some more effects. I.e those are just smudges with a render places on outter glow.
3. Don't use bevel and things that makes the render "Pop" out.

[cgrock]

Thanks for feedback... but did you ever think mabye i made some of them pop out? (ex.) the dragon... (on purpose)

~Thanks Cgrock~

[Clain]

What i meant by that was....like sometimes you don't need to/it ruins your sig when you try to make it pop out by setting it on bevel and emboss

[Guybrush]

I think that the last sig looks totally awesome! 12/10 for that one. The other two I'm not as keen on.

on the top two the background and text dont really match IMO. 6/10

But hey, that's just my oppinion.

[Juicyz]

I know you said dont critize on the second one, but it would look better if u darkened the fourhead...... It stands out.

[Piersd]

i really like the third one, but the big ugly text and the beveled border ruins it for me. try to stay away from bevel, it usually looks cool when you first start, but then you realise it looks pretty bad after all this time

Over all i think you should add some different effects instead of a duplicate render and then smudging it or liquifying it. Get some brushes, follow tutorials and try different things. And most of all, stay away from bevel lol

[Shinyshoes]

Sigh..I'm not even going to CC, I'm sorry. All I want to say is that people need to take a look at some tutorials. These just look cheesy man, you have some great ideas you just need more of a guideline to follow, then you will improve. If you need links to improve just pm me.

[Bob_Magic]

This just looks like you got a picture, smudged it, beveled it, put an outer glow and stuck your name on it. I don't like all three to be frank. the way you build a sig is to have depth and flow... I cannot find that anywhere in these three. Remember to always use colours that will compliment the render.

-Bob