[Decision] New sig

[Bob_Magic]

Ok so I made this new signature and wasn't sure whether to use it or not over my current one. I would like your criticisms and opinons

[Volcano]

I dont know why, but it think its a fashion thing but.. Why do the most signature creators make their name into the light thing so ya cant see the text? i hate it, Piersd make it like that, not because i dont like his stuff because i do, but it annoy me that i really have to look after the little text. And for me it only looks like "Bo B." 7/10

[Nemorosa]

Yeah it's better in my opinion.

[CarlosJ]

i choose your current one over that, although its nice and a change overall i feel your current one is a better sig. but i really like the render for this it just makes me

mainly for me with the sig im just confused about the style of it and the focus (apart from the render). it appears extremely bright and the detail that is visible seems to be half finished (mainly referring to the splatter by the renders right arm)
the right hand side of the sig i really like, because of the colour blending and the effects and flow it has but i feel the middle left side of the sig lacks the depth and flow to continue the sig. the far left i think looks nice with the shadows to provide depth but my eye doesn't move smoothly from side to side of the sig.
but i do like it despite all this, mainly because of its originality and in parts simplicity.

@ Volcano: many people use the "subtle" text because generally it is recognised as more "professional". depending on the situation normally text should be subtle. sigs are just like art, when you look at the mona lisa (lol stupid example) you dont look for da vanci's signature you look at the art. its much like this, when some sigs contain big bold text it sometimes just shows a lack of thought and care on its choice/placement. its one of the key things that many people get wrong with sigs. i agree some situations e.g. a cartoon like sig big text works but normally it doesnt, its about the art not the text, the text complements the art work itself.

[.Cyong]

i like it, but the pink doesnt go with it and that random smudge is ugly to the left of him and thats what caught my attn right when i saw it, other than that, its great

[EliMob441]

Whats up with that smudge?

[Bob_Magic]

Yeah.. I thought It looked a bit out of place. Really just trying to find my own style atm. I think i'm better when i use C4D